Research Sheds Light on How Nature has Optimized Photosynthesis

Photosynthesis plays a crucial role in shaping and sustaining life on Earth, yet many aspects of the process remain a mystery. One such mystery is how Photosystem II, a protein complex in plants, algae and cyanobacteria, harvests energy from sunlight and uses it to split water, producing the oxygen we breathe. Now researchers from the Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, together with collaborators from Uppsala University and Humboldt University and other institutions have succeeded in cracking a key secret of Photosystem II.

Using SLAC's Linac Coherent Light Source (LCLS) and the SPring-8 Angstrom Compact free electron LAser (SACLA) in Japan, they captured for the first time in atomic detail what happens in the final moments leading up to the release of breathable oxygen. The data reveal an intermediate reaction step that had not been observed before.

The results, published today in Nature, shed light on how nature has optimized photosynthesis and are helping scientists develop artificial photosynthetic systems that mimic photosynthesis to harvest natural sunlight to convert carbon dioxide into hydrogen and carbon based-fuels.

The more we learn about how nature does it, the closer we get to using those same principles in human-made processes, including ideas for artificial photosynthesis as a clean and sustainable energy source."

Jan Kern, co-author, scientist at Berkeley Lab

Co-author Junko Yano, also at Berkeley Lab, said, "Photosystem II is giving us the blueprint for how to optimize our clean energy sources and avoid dead ends and dangerous side products that damage the system. What we once thought was just fundamental science could become a promising avenue to improving our energy technologies."

Bases Loaded

During photosynthesis, Photosystem II's oxygen-evolving center – a cluster of four manganese atoms and one calcium atom connected by oxygen atoms – facilitates a series of challenging chemical reactions that act to split apart a water molecule to release molecular oxygen.

The center cycles through four stable oxidation states, known as S₀ through S₃, when exposed to sunlight. On a baseball field, S₀ would be the start of the game when a player on home base is ready to go to bat. S₁-S₃ would be players on first, second, and third. Every time a batter connects with a ball, or the complex absorbs a photon of sunlight, the player on the field advances one base. When the fourth ball is hit, the player slides into home, scoring a run or, in the case of Photosystem II, releasing one molecule of breathable oxygen.

In their experiments, the researchers probed this center by exciting samples from cyanobacteria with optical light and then probing them with ultrafast X-ray pulses from LCLS and SACLA. The data revealed the atomic structure of the cluster and the chemical process around it.

A Homerun

Using this technique, the scientists for the first time imaged the mad dash for home – the transient state, or S₄, where two atoms of oxygen bond together and an oxygen molecule is released. The data showed that there are additional steps in this reaction that had never been seen before.

"Other experts argued that this is something that could never be captured," said co-author Uwe Bergmann, a scientist and professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. "It's really going to change the way we think about Photosystem II. Although we can't say we have a unique mechanism based on the data yet, we can exclude some models and ideas people have proposed over the last few decades. It's the closest anyone has ever come to capturing this final step and showing how this process works with actual structural data."

The new study is the latest in a series undertaken by the team over the past decade. Earlier work focused on observing various steps of the photosynthetic cycle at the temperature at which it occurs in nature.

"Most of the process that produces breathable oxygen happens in this last step," said co-author Vittal Yachandra, a scientist at Berkeley Lab. "But there are several things happening at different parts of photosystem II and they all have to come together in the end for the reaction to succeed. Just like how in baseball, factors like the location of the ball and the position of the basemen and fielders affect the moves a player takes to get to home base, the protein environment around the catalytic center influences how this reaction plays out."

Brighter X-Rays for a Brighter Future

Based on these results, the researchers plan to conduct experiments designed to capture many more snapshots of the process.

"There are still things happening in between that we could not catch yet," Kern said. "There are more snapshots we really want to take which would bridge the remaining gaps and tell the whole story."

To do so, they need to push the quality of their data even further. In the past, these types of measurements proved challenging because the X-ray signals from the samples are faint and the rates at which existing X-ray lasers like LCLS and SACLA produce X-ray pulses are too small.

"It took quite some effort to optimize the setup, so we couldn't collect all the data we needed for this one publication in a single experiment," said co-author and SLAC scientist Roberto Alonso-Mori. "These results actually include data taken over six years."

When an LCLS upgrade, called LCLS-II, comes online later this year, the repetition rate will skyrocket from 120 pulses per second to up to a million per second.

"With these upgrades, we will be able to collect several days' worth of data in just a few hours," Bergmann said. "We will also be able to use soft X-rays to further understand the chemical changes happening in the system. These new capabilities will continue to drive this research forward and shed new light on photosynthesis."